< Back to All News

Couple’s Suit Denied by Federal Court

A Penn Valley couple continues to experience frustration in regards to the permitting of a cell tower to be built on property adjacent to their own. The couple wants to build a home office on top of their garage that would put it above the ridge line at roughly the same height as the approved cell tower.  The county approved the permit for the cell tower, but denied the permit for the home office that Juliet Erickson and Peter Lockyer wanted to build.

According to County Counsel Alllison Barrat-Green Lockeyer and Erickson sued the county claiming a violation of equal protection.
On March 26 the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District granted Nevada County’s motion to dismiss the couples legal challenge .
Click here to listen to County Counsel Allison Barratt-Green

In rejecting the claim, the Court held that the residential permit and the communications tower permit were distinctly different approvals subject to different requirements under the County’s Land Use and Development code.  Since Erickson and Lockyer could not demonstrate that they were “similarly situated” to the cell tower applicant, the Court dismissed the federal equal protection claim without leave to amend their complaint.

The Federal Court declined to address the remaining state law claims and then dismissed the case.  County Counsel expects Erickson and Lockyer to refile those claims in State Court.

1 Comment

July 1, 2013


Are we really letting these people, probably from the city hold up the process of installing a cell phone tower? We need this tower and the sooner the better. I would like to know when it's going up?


KNCO Web Comments Guidelines

  1. Keep it clean. Comments with inappropriate language, no matter how cleverly spelled or decorated will not be posted.
  2. Comments on the way the story was written or misspelled words will be passed on to the story authors and not posted.
  3. Please use your real name. Anonymous comments or comments posted using a fake name or web handle may not be posted.
  4. Please use your real email address so we can contact you.
  5. No flaming. Any comments that are primarily of a name calling finger pointing nature may not be posted.
  6. The comment section is not a right it is a privilege. KNCO retains all rights as to what is posted on its website.

Leave A Comment



* captcha